Hard Questions

Isn’t believing in Jesus, trying to serve God, and being a decent person enough?

⏱️ 3 min read 📝 580 words
In Brief

Faith in Christ matters infinitely. Striving to serve God matters. Being a decent person matters. But "isn’t that enough?" reduces the Christianity Christ instituted to a fraction of itself: bypassing the Church, the sacraments, the moral life in its fullness, and the lifelong call to sanctity. He offered more than the question imagines.

The position behind this question is widespread, sincere, and far better than indifference. A person who actually believes in Christ, actually tries to serve God, and actually attempts to live decently is closer to the Kingdom than millions of his more sophisticated contemporaries. The Catholic answer is not “you are wrong.” The Catholic answer is “Christ asked for more, and offered more, than your formula imagines.”

Belief in Jesus and moral effort are the foundation. Christ raised a building on that foundation. He commanded baptism: “Going therefore, teach ye all nations; baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost” (Matthew 28:19). He instituted the Eucharist with the words “Do this in commemoration of me” (Luke 22:19), and made plain that “except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you” (John 6:53). He gave the apostles authority to forgive sins (John 20:23). He founded a visible Church on Peter and promised the gates of hell would not prevail against her (Matthew 16:18). To accept Christ but reject the things He instituted is to take the Founder while declining the foundation. None of these are optional accessories to the Faith. They are the Faith.

The slogan rests on a quiet assumption, that everything Christ established after Pentecost (the visible Church, the sacraments, the apostolic ministry, the Eucharist as His Body and Blood) is decoration rather than substance. But Christ did not preach a generic spirituality. He founded a Church and told the apostles He sent: “He that heareth you, heareth me; and he that despiseth you, despiseth me” (Luke 10:16). He did not say “as long as people believe in me and try to be good, they have heard me.” He gave specific commands to specific men whose successors govern the Church to this day. To bypass them is to bypass the means He chose to reach you.

On “being a decent person”: decency is genuinely good, and Catholic moral theology has a place for it. Natural virtue is real virtue. But decency is not the standard Christ set. He did not say, “Be decent, and inherit the Kingdom.” He said, “Be ye therefore perfect, as also your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matthew 5:48). He told us to love our enemies, to take up our cross, to deny ourselves, to forgive without limit. These are not the moral commitments of a decent neighbor; they are the moral commitments of a saint. The Christian life aspires to sanctity, not to passing the test of being not-too-bad. Decency is the start of the road, not its end. To make decency the standard is to exempt yourself from the rest of the journey.

Catholics do not consign the casually religious to hell, only God reads souls, and a sincere believer who lives uprightly may be saved by the grace operative even where his theology is incomplete. But the apologist’s job is to make plain what is being missed. To stop at “believe in Jesus and be a decent person” is to forfeit the sacraments, the Church, the saints as companions on the way, the moral and spiritual patrimony of two thousand years, and the Eucharist itself. The Mass is open. The confessional is open. The whole life Christ made possible is sitting there waiting. The Catholic answer to this question is not “you are damned.” It is, “He gave us so much more — come and see what you are missing.”

Share on Social Media
Share this answer