‹ The Bishops
James S. Wall
Living · United States · Bishop

James S. Wall

Bishop of Gallup
Bishop
1964
1998
Ordained
2009
Consecrated Bishop
Gallup
Diocese
United States
Country
The Life

James Sean Wall was born on October 11, 1964, in Ganado, Arizona, in the Navajo Nation, one of six children of James and Joan Wall, converts who had come into the Church through two Franciscan friars. A Chandler High School graduate (1983), he took a history degree at Arizona State University in 1993 and entered St. John's Seminary in Camarillo, earning a Master of Divinity in 1998, with further study at the Liturgical Institute at Mundelein. He was ordained a priest for the Diocese of Phoenix on June 6, 1998.

He was parochial vicar at St. Theresa in Phoenix and St. Timothy in Mesa, then pastor of St. Thomas the Apostle in Phoenix (2002-2007). He then served as vicar for priests, briefly as administrator of a Scottsdale parish, and as director of the Mount Claret Retreat Center, and sat on the USCCB's National Advisory Council. On February 5, 2009, Pope Benedict XVI named him the fourth Bishop of Gallup; he was consecrated and installed that April at Sacred Heart Cathedral in Gallup.

Gallup covers some 55,000 square miles of New Mexico and Arizona and is often called the poorest diocese in the United States; much of it is Native American mission country - Navajo, Hopi, Zuni and Apache. His episcopate has been marked by hard reckoning: in 2013 the diocese entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy to settle clergy-abuse claims, emerging in 2017, and in 2023 he returned St. Michael's Mission to diocesan operation from the Franciscans. His episcopal motto is Estote factores verbi - "Be doers of the word."

Major Works & Initiatives
Chapter 11 reorganization of the Diocese of Gallup
Led the diocese through a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filed in 2013 to settle clergy sexual-abuse claims; the case closed in 2017, and the diocese published a list of credibly accused clergy.
St. Michael's Mission returned to diocesan operation
In May 2023 announced that the diocese was taking over operation of St. Michael's Mission from the Franciscans.
League of the Blessed Sacrament ordered out (2025)
In 2025 ordered a group of young men in Concho, expelled four years earlier from the Canons Regular of the Immaculate Conception, to vacate parish-owned housing and stop teaching in Catholic schools, stating that the group had no official status in the Church.
In His Own Words
Controversies
Clergy sexual-abuse claims and the 2013 bankruptcy
Abuse claims against Gallup clergy, many predating his episcopate, forced the 2013 Chapter 11 filing. The diocese's 2014 list named 42 clergy and one lay teacher with credible accusations; by 2017 it had paid more than $17.6 million in settlements to 57 victims, and survivors criticized diocesan record-keeping during the case.
The Old Mass, See by See
Gallup2009-04-23 – presentNo act of his own
What he inheritedNo provision for the 1962 Missal in the Diocese of Gallup has been documented at any point in Bishop Wall's tenure, before or after 16 July 2021: no diocesan site, no society apostolate, and no decree or statement. There was no inherited old-Mass community for the motu proprio to affect, and he created none.
  • 2019-06-20Directed that the 11:00 a.m. Sunday Mass at Sacred Heart Cathedral be celebrated ad orientem from Corpus Christi 2019 and encouraged the practice diocese-wide. The act concerned the reformed Missal, not the 1962 Missal, and predates Traditionis custodes; it is context, not a posture act. (Cited to the Wayback capture: the original CNA URL was retired when CNA moved to EWTN News and now redirects to a home page.) ↗
Since the SSPX decree of 2 July 2026: No statement recorded as of 2026-10-23.
Reviewed 2026-10-23Confidence: medium
Domus Dei’s Verdict
The Bishop & the Mass of Ages
No public record on the old Mass

No Traditional Latin Mass offered under diocesan authority, and no decree or statement by Bishop Wall on the old Mass, has been found in the sources consulted, before or after Traditionis custodes. The CNA survey of diocesan responses in July 2021 lists Gallup as N/A, and no FSSP, ICKSP, or other society apostolate is present in the diocese.

His one documented traditional-adjacent act predates the motu proprio and did not concern the 1962 Missal: in 2019 he directed that the 11:00 a.m. Sunday Mass at Sacred Heart Cathedral be celebrated ad orientem - the reformed Mass facing the altar - and encouraged the practice across the diocese. On the old Mass itself, nothing happened: no act of permission, restriction, or suppression is documented, and his posture is recorded as no_record, plainly.

References & Further Reading
1.
Bishop James Sean Wall — Catholic-Hierarchy (David M. Cheney) · catholic-hierarchy.orgBishop ID bwalljs verified against the project's cached CH listings and the CH Gallup diocese page: appointed 5 Feb 2009.
2.
Bishop James Wall (profile) — Catholic Answers · catholic.comStates he was consecrated and installed on April 23, 2009; basis for the possession date.
3.
Bishop Wall introduces regular ad orientem Mass at Gallup cathedral — Catholic News Agency · catholicnewsagency.com · 2019His 2019 ad orientem decision for the cathedral's 11:00 a.m. Sunday Mass (reformed Missal); pre-TC context.
4.
Pope Francis' Traditional Latin Mass restrictions: Has your diocese responded yet? — National Catholic Register (CNA survey) · ncregister.com · 2021Gallup listed as N/A in the July 2021 survey of diocesan responses.
5.
Diocese of Gallup, N.M., poised to file for bankruptcy protection — Joseph J. Kolb (CNS) · catholicsun.org · 2013The 2013 Chapter 11 announcement and Bishop Wall's letter.
6.
James S. Wall — Wikipedia · en.wikipedia.orgBiographical detail; its article text gives April 2, 2009 for the consecration, against April 23 in the Catholic Answers profile and other bios - flagged in the batch notes.
Portrait: Diocese of Gallup / Wikimedia Commons
Share on Social Media